On Kenny on Aquinas on Being : A Critical Review of Aquinas on Being by Anthony Kenny
نویسندگان
چکیده
Gyula Klima, Review of A. Kenny: Aquinas on Mind (New York: Routledge, 1995) in Faith and Philosophy 15 (1998) 113–17. In this essay I will only deal with Kenny’s charges against Aquinas’s doctrine that directly concern Aquinas’s doctrine of being, namely, the charge of his failure to distinguish “specifi c existence” from “individual being” à la Frege, and the charges against Aquinas’s doctrine of God as ipsum esse subsistens. But I will not deal here with Kenny’s objections to Aquinas’s doctrine of separate substances, based on what I take to be Kenny’s inadequate grasp of Aquinas’s distinction between the modes of signifi cation of abstract and concrete terms, which I have dealt with in the review referred to in the previous note. See Kenny’s summary of his three main charges on pp. 192–93. On Kenny on Aquinas on Being: A Critical Review of Aquinas on Being by Anthony Kenny
منابع مشابه
Comparative Study of Aquinas and Kant‘s Narration of Ethics and Theology
Since Kant is a son of his time, his thought is originally rooted in the Enlightenment. The distinction between theoretical and practical reason, formal and material conscientiousness, authentic and doctrinal theodicy, sincerity and falsehood, and finally, historical and moral faith religion, are implications of the court held by Kant for metaphysics. Meanwhile, Kantian distinction between deis...
متن کاملAn Apophatic View of God and Creation
The English Dominican Herbert McCabe highlighted some ideas of Thomas Aquinas on the knowability of God and on creation, which can usefully challenge some widespread commonplaces. The purposes of this article are two: to present McCabe’s sophisticated doctrine on the knowability of God and on creation in a systematic way, and to put this doctrine into its historical context. In the scattered an...
متن کاملSpinoza on Method
By interrupting the traditional approach to the distinctiveness of the order of knowledge and the order of nature (which was the procedure of many philosophers like Aristotle, and his scholastic disciples, more especially of Thomas Aquinas and even Descartes and Cartesian), and acquiring a unified science, Spinoza changes the customary order of philosophizing and begins his famous book, Ethics,...
متن کاملA Comparative Study on Political Theology in Western and Islamic Political Thought
The science of the word and theology considered as expertise in area of concern of Islam religion in which it discusses about religious principle, approach and worldview based on rational and narrative reasoning and answer to doubts that pose in this area; in Christianity and in general through all monotheism religions, it could be possible to use this method for religious reasoning, it could b...
متن کاملPsychology and mind in Aquinas.
This article stresses the main lines of Thomas Aquinas's philosophy on the nature of the body-soul union. Following Aristotle, Aquinas sees the soul as a 'principle of life' which is intimately bound to a body. Together they form a non-contingent composition. In addition, the distinctive feature of the human soul is rationality, which implies that a human needs a mind to be what it is. However,...
متن کامل